You’re out for a casual coffee with a friend – someone you haven’t known for very long, but you’ve been spending more time together lately and you’re enjoying their company. You ask how they’ve been, and they proceed to tell you much, much more than you expected. All of a sudden, they’re sharing deeply traumatic experiences, and you’re caught off guard and unprepared.
Sharing our emotional experiences is human, but when someone offloads deep personal experiences without checking in first, they could be trauma dumping. It’s normal to want to share emotional experiences – 88-96% of our emotional experiences are socially shared – but traumatic experiences don’t follow the same rules as everyday emotions.1
Trauma dumping is a pop-psychology term, not one that psychologists use clinically or academically – although research on trauma dumping is beginning to surface. We can use this and earlier research on social sharing and disclosure to examine the psychology of trauma dumping, including through an attachment lens.
This article will explore why people trauma dump, what happens when you trauma dump, and how to recognize and respond to trauma dumping in your relationships.
DISCOVER YOUR ATTACHMENT STYLE
Trauma dumping is inappropriately sharing sensitive personal and emotional information without asking the recipient first. One study defined the difference between trauma dumping and healthy sharing:2
“…and healthy emotional disclosure are not the same thing. Where the latter tends to be mutual, intentional, and often occurring within the context of a known and trusting relationship, trauma dumping tends to be abrupt, one-sided, and occurring in contextually inappropriate situations.”
Most definitions of trauma dumping include 4 main characteristics:
It can be difficult to tell the difference between trauma dumping and “venting”. When we’re venting, we’re also sharing an emotional experience with someone else, usually in a one-sided manner. So, what’s the difference between trauma dumping and venting?
The line is crossed when the information being shared is no longer contextually appropriate, making the recipient uncomfortable – in other words, it’s too deep for the person or environment. For example, sharing your traumatic experiences with your therapist during a session would be okay, but it wouldn’t be okay to offload if you bumped into them at the grocery store.
LEARN TO REGULATE YOUR EMOTIONS
Trauma dumping could happen in almost any setting. Here are a few common examples of trauma dumping that you might recognize:
The common thread in these examples is that the recipient of the information is unprepared and uncomfortable. Although Olive (example 2) can’t see the reactions of the people who see her post, and may have even attached a content warning, it’s likely the audience won’t have been expecting deep personal disclosure.
To check if you might be trauma dumping, ask yourself these questions:
If the answer to any of these questions is no, then you may be trauma dumping.
It’s normal to want to share emotional experiences, but trauma dumping clearly has more negative consequences than benefits. So, why do we trauma dump?
Until further research explores trauma dumping specifically, it’s difficult to pinpoint exactly why we trauma dump. Psychologists have suggested a few potential reasons:2
We tend to think that getting something off our chest will make us feel better, but research has actually shown that the relief we get from “just venting” is only temporary.1,3 It feels good when the person we’re talking to gives us care, reassurance, and validation, but it doesn’t help us to make sense of our experiences.
Instead, talking to someone who’s able to help us reframe or understand our experience differently can lead to lower feelings of distress and better recovery. Therefore, if we keep trauma dumping on people who aren’t prepared to go through the experience with us, we might only gain temporary relief which leads us to feel the need to share again – leading us to continue a cycle of trauma dumping.
Trauma dumping, by definition, involves sharing trauma. However, not everybody who has experienced trauma has post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD.
PTSD is a clinical diagnosis that can only be made by a qualified practitioner. It’s characterized by intrusive symptoms, avoidance, and changes in mood and nervous system behaviors following experiencing, witnessing, or other exposure to a traumatic event.
It’s suggested that oversharing in the form of trauma dumping is a sign of unprocessed trauma.2 However, researchers have found that people with PTSD are actually less likely to want to share their experiences than people with trauma who don’t meet PTSD diagnostic criteria.1 This makes sense, because PTSD includes avoiding memories or reminders of the trauma, and often comes with feelings of shame around what happened.
So, is oversharing a trauma response? It’s possible – but you might be experiencing more severe trauma if you’re actively avoiding oversharing, rather than trauma dumping.
There are lots of other reasons we might overshare. Finding it difficult to know when to stop sharing doesn’t necessarilt mean you have trauma or PTSD. If you’re finding your emotions or experiences difficult to cope with, a qualified mental health professional can help you to learn more about what’s happening for you and explore options for further support.
Sharing emotional experiences is intrinsically linked to our attachment styles – according to one study, the desire to share an emotion arises from our attachment needs, and elicits an attachment response from the listener.1
We still need more research to fully understand the connection between attachment styles and trauma dumping, but we can use what we know about attachment and emotional sharing to theorize.
If the need to share an emotion comes from an activated attachment system, and attachment anxiety is associated with an overactivated attachment system, then it could be the case that having an anxious attachment style makes you more likely to share – and at higher risk of trauma dumping.
In the context of attachment needs, you could be trauma dumping in an effort to create connection or fast-track intimacy. Some people call this floodlighting. You might not necessarily be manipulating the relationship on purpose, but you might still be putting too much pressure on the other person too soon.
DISCOVER YOUR ATTACHMENT STYLE
On the other hand, if attachment avoidance is associated with an underactivated attachment system, then we might suggest that people with attachment avoidance could be less likely to share their emotions and less at risk of trauma dumping.
This would make sense based on what we understand about attachment avoidance; building intimacy and trust can feel uncomfortable for people with avoidant attachment styles, so sharing emotions – especially big ones – can be a bigger deal for them than for people with lower attachment avoidance.
If you have the fearful-avoidant attachment style, your attachment system can alternate between under- and overactivated. Your tendency to share emotions and risk of trauma dumping could be less predictable.
Although trauma dumping can be a bid for connection, it tends to have the opposite effect. An editorial by leading nursing academics Dr. Michelle Cleary and Prof. Debra Jackson described being on the receiving end of trauma dumping as:
“…more than just awkward, it can be emotionally draining and potentially triggering. The emotional remains can linger. We may carry someone else’s grief, rage, or fear for hours, days or weeks.”2
Vicarious trauma is a real type of trauma in which exposure to the details of someone else’s trauma produces its own trauma symptoms. In other words, trauma dumping can traumatize others. Therapists and other professionals who are routinely exposed to other people’s trauma have an understanding of this and systems in place to manage it, but oversharing outside of this professional environment can leave people feeling at risk themselves.
The need to share is human, and you shouldn’t feel ashamed for feeling the need to share your experiences with others. However, relationships can only thrive when we respect each other’s boundaries.
Dr. Cleary and Prof. Jackson highlight the importance of consent in sharing traumatic experiences.2 Asking someone if they’re ready to hear intense emotional information, ensuring they’re in a safe space to pause or stop the conversation if they need to, and respecting their boundaries helps both of you feel supported and heard.
Emotional regulation skills are very important here. Not only do you need to be aware of how you’re feeling so that you know whether you’re about to disclose something highly emotional, but you also need to be sure that you can cope if the other person isn’t ready to hear it.
The first step in practicing emotional regulation is emotional recognition. Are you able to notice when you start to feel anxious, upset, or angry? Do you have an awareness of how it feels in your body or the thoughts that come up when you’re about to trauma dump on someone? When you have this awareness, you can take a step back and decide how to navigate the situation. Mindfulness can be really useful in practicing emotional recognition.
Once you recognize that you feel these feelings, do you have the coping skills you need to manage them? Are you able to use grounding or soothing techniques to let the feeling pass? These could be really useful if the other person isn’t ready to hear what you have to share. This can feel like a rejection, but remember, another person’s willingness to hear traumatic information reflects their own internal state, not their relationship with you.
In summary, practice the following skills if you’re habitually trauma dumping:
Ideally, practice these skills in safe environments before you’re in a situation where you need them. This makes them easier to access when needed.
If you are routinely on the receiving end of trauma dumping, there are two things you likely want to know: how to respond to trauma dumping, and how to tell someone to stop trauma dumping.
This section assumes you want to respond with support – we’ll get into how to respond with boundaries and tell someone to stop in the next section.
When someone’s trauma dumping, they are likely looking for connection. Start with empathic statements like “that must have been really difficult for you”, and “that sounds really scary”. Although this provides temporary relief, it does potentially reinforce trauma dumping behavior.
Once the person who’s trauma dumping feels safer and more regulated, you can try prompting cognitive reframing to support emotional recovery. This involves validating that the other person’s reactions are normal, while also considering positive ways to look at the experience.
Depending on the situation, this can be really tricky to do successfully – if you feel out of your depth, it’s better to put boundaries in place and point the other person towards a mental health professional.
If you or your relationship with the other person are suffering due to their trauma dumping, it can be beneficial to both of you in the long-term to put in boundaries – even if the other person takes it as a rejection at first.
Remember that you can’t pour from an empty cup, and sometimes it’s necessary to put yourself first so that you can be the best friend you can be. You aren’t your friend’s therapist, and you can’t be expected to give them everything they need when they’re working through traumatic experiences. This doesn’t make you a bad friend.
With this in mind, if your friend is consistently trauma dumping, boundaries can help both of you to feel clear on what you can manage. Your boundary might be putting a complete stop to certain topics, or it might be that you just want them to ask for consent before they share certain things. When you communicate boundaries, include the reason and what your response will be if the boundary is crossed – remember boundaries are for you, not for you to regulate your friend’s behavior.
It’s best to communicate your boundary before it’s next needed, since your friend might already be feeling emotionally dysregulated when trauma dumping and can find it more difficult to respond to perceived rejection.
Your boundaries are personal to you, but examples include:
A qualified mental health practitioner can help your friend to work through the emotional side of trauma dumping and start the cognitive process of emotional recovery.
LEARN TO REGULATE YOUR EMOTIONS
Needing to share is human, but trauma dumping can have consequences for your relationship. The person you’re trauma dumping on might feel uncomfortable, burdened, or even triggered themselves.
Although you might be looking for empathy and connection from trauma dumping, getting these responses could actually reinforce trauma dumping and lead to a trauma dumping cycle. A qualified mental health practitioner can help you to start the cognitive work needed to recover from an emotional experience. In the meantime, practicing emotional regulation skills can help you to stop trauma dumping.
If your friend or someone else in your life is trauma dumping on you, recognize that setting boundaries isn’t selfish. Rather, it preserves your relationship and ensures you can continue to be there for your friend in the capacity that you can be. Setting boundaries involves recognizing that your friend’s feelings are valid and that you want to be there for them, but communicating how you’ll respond to maintain your own wellbeing in the future if they continue trauma dumping.
Building a secure attachment style can support better emotional regulation. To find out more, explore our resources.
Trauma dumping has negative consequences on your relationships. The person on the receiving end of trauma dumping might feel burdened, uncomfortable, or triggered, even if they want to be there for you.
If your friend is repeatedly trauma dumping, consider setting boundaries. Explain how putting your wellbeing first helps you to continue to be there for them, and be clear on how you’ll respond if your boundary is crossed. This isn’t intended to be a punishment. You can also gently point your friend in the direction of a qualified mental health practitioner, who would have the skills and experience needed to give them the right support.
If you’re sharing intense emotional experiences in a one-sided manner, without the recipient’s consent and in unexpected contexts, then you may be trauma dumping. The line between venting and trauma dumping is crossed when the situation is no longer contextually appropriate.
Trauma dumping can happen on social media. If you’re posting intense emotional experiences in places where people won’t be expecting to hear about them, then you may be trauma dumping – even if it comes with a warning.
Emotion dumping can be another word for trauma dumping. This describes unexpectedly sharing intense emotional experiences, which leaves the other person feeling uncomfortable.